I have never been too fond of vanilla scents. I gravitate towards either lavender or fruity/flowery scents.
But now I found this! I bought it at Bath and Body Works. Every vanilla scent I have ever tried has been overpowering. This one smells almost like cake. I love it! It's called Warm Vanilla Sugar and I am not sure how long this scent has been around, all I know is I was missing out.